Grenfell - the symptoms vs the disease

After considering fire safety in a previous blog, we now turn to look at the issues caused by regulations and lack of enforcement.

There are rightly calls for wholesale change and after years of sniping at ‘unnecessary regulations’ we may have to reverse the attempts at cutting red tape. 

But what were those regulations that were consigned to history, might they have led to this tragedy?  That is a more difficult question to answer.  We all complain about red tape but when asked which regulations would you like to get rid of, invariably a room full of construction specialists will be unable to name one.  In fact they will usually include some they feel should be added. 

So it is not necessarily that the government has revoked some essential piece of safety regulation, it is more that they have set the tone.  Regulation is an unnecessary impediment to innovation and progress, usually dreamed up by some faceless bureaucrat that the government can do nothing about, but accept and implement.

As a consequence you have a culture of non-enforcement.  The biggest complaint of specialist contractors is that building regulations are paid lip service.  There are precious few prosecutions for a failure meet the requirements of building standards and none for a failure to comply with the energy efficiency targets described in Part L of building regulations. When challenged, DCLG, the department responsible for building regulations, ask “what should we do call in the building police?”

At the very least there is a culture of neglect, as we have seen with the delays to Part B of building regulations, which include fire regulations.   In fact the role of Building Control has progressively been downgraded, with the provision of private providers, this adds a commercial dimension to the checking of buildings. It is not about doing a thorough inspection, it’s ‘can you do it cheaply’ and ‘can you help get around more expensive requirements by beneficially interpreting regulations?’ 

The process was clearly identified in the recently published Edinburgh Schools Report into the closure of 17 schools in Edinburgh following a wall collapse;

A number of witnesses to the Inquiry identified a desire to reduce the cost of fees as a major factor in deciding the level of provision of effective inspection of construction, rather than a serious assessment of the risks of not providing for adequate independent scrutiny

Consequently, with little or no chance of prosecution, a culture of non-compliance is prevalent.  And this is portrayed, or it was until Grenfell, as a victimless crime. 

This culture of neglect will hopefully be addressed and redressed with Dame Judith Hackitt, Chair of the Engineering Employers Federation, leading a new independent review of Building Regulations. The review announced on Friday as part of the continuing response to the Grenfell tragedy and is the first opportunity for meaningful review of Building Regulations in many years. At the BESA, we are encouraged by the broader focus of this review and its focus on tall buildings, compliance and enforcement.

Read our 4th blog in the series for some suggestions of how we might address this contentious issue.

Recent News

BESA National Conference speakers announced

SFG20 tops the bill with Mark Farmer and BBC Business Doctor at BESA's first ever National Conference in London on 19 October.

Link Continue Reading


Grenfell - less speed more haste - when will we learn?

Part 6 of our Grenfell series questions whether the construction teams’ views were listened to.

Link Continue Reading


Grenfell- flues, chimneys and exhausts - installation and maintenance

Part 5 of our series moves onto a key part of a passive fire safety strategy; flues and exhausts.

Link Continue Reading


Grenfell -The symptoms vs the disease - a solution

Part 4 of our series explores the difference between legislation and regulations.

Link Continue Reading


Grenfell - fire stopping systems

Part 2 of our Grenfell series - What else are we missing - looks at fire stopping systems.

Link Continue Reading


Grenfell - what else are we missing?

Part 1 of our series outlines the fire risks associated with the poor cleaning of ventilation systems.

Link Continue Reading


SFG20 launches approved provider scheme

SFG20 has launched an Approved Provider Partnership and welcomes its first company to gain approved provider status Asckey Data Services Ltd.

Link Continue Reading


Industry bodies agree single process for BIM product data

Three leading construction industry bodies have moved to clear up growing confusion over the process of standardising product information for use in Building Information Modelling (BIM).

Link Continue Reading


Industry bodies agree standard for catering maintenance

SFG20 in collaboration with CESA has launched the first ever independently verified standard for the planned maintenance of catering equipment.

Link Continue Reading


Energy efficiency could cut NHS costs by £400m

Good news for the health sector in the wake of the Carter Report as a HTM (Health Technical Memorandum) module is now available, providing maintenance schedules aligned with the requirements of the HTMs.

Link Continue Reading


70% of office workers complain about poor air quality

A new survey has found that indoor air pollution is prevalent in work places across Britain, potentially causing long-term health problems.

Link Continue Reading


SFG20 now includes schedules relating to specialist areas such as catering

26/11/2015 From today, Customiser Compliance and Service Model subscribers can access a range of Specialist Schedules covering catering, lifts & access equipment and workshop equipment.

Link Continue Reading


SFG20's Bruce Kirton presents on the importance of planned maintenance strategies

20/10/2015 Visit CIBSE's Building Performance Conference on November 3rd and 4th to hear about the benefits a planned maintenance strategy can deliver to your business.

Link Continue Reading


Primary users can now set various access rights for different users

22.07.2015 From today, Primary Users at both Customiser Compliance and Service Model levels can assign access rights to users.

Link Continue Reading


Service Model subscribers can now customise service times

24.04.15 Today we are excited to announce the launch of customisable service times for our Service Model subscribers.

Link Continue Reading


New Service Model functionality and customer website now live

12/01/2015 A streamlined user interface for Service Model users has gone live today, in addition to a new-look customer website.

Link Continue Reading


Service times now added for Service Model subscribers

1/12/14 Schedules now display the end-to-end service time to complete the tasks on an individual maintenance schedule.

Link Continue Reading


SFG20 wins government grant to develop a BIM interface

11/08/14 Enabling the automatic generation of customised maintenance solutions from BIM models and informing whole-life design decisions, with collaboration between construction and facilities management teams.

Link Continue Reading


SFG20 wins at the prestigious 2013 H&V News Awards

26/04/2013 SFG20 won in the Service and Maintenance Initiative of the Year category, being judged as "innovative" and having the potential to transform the service and maintenance sector.

Link Continue Reading